We read an essay called The Singer Solution to World Poverty today in English class. It addresses (as you may have cleverly deduced from the title) the situation of world poverty and gives a "solution" to it, presented systematically with a few examples.
I had some problems with the logic, though.
In all honesty, I found this essay to be written with a strong pre-determined bias. Hey, you might argue, argumentative essays have to have a pre-determined side to take. Yes, that's true, but I felt that this essay did not present that side in an open-minded manner. For example, in Singer's first example, about a Dora, a retired school teacher who gets $1000 by unknowingly delivering a street boy in Brazil to organ peddlers. Here, Singer tells us that Dora didn't know what she was doing (she had been told that he would be adopted by right foreigners). Later, however, he starts to talk about Dora's actions as if they were intentional. Check this out: "Unlike Dora, Bob did not have to look into the eyes of the child he was sacrificing for his own material comfort" (Singer 2). Wouldn't that sentence support the presumption that Dora knowingly led the boy to his demise? Dora could easily look the boy in the eyes, thinking that she was leading him to a better life in another country. Had Dora known that his organs would be removed, of course, looking him in the eyes would be very difficult. This just wasn't the case.
Singer's second example, about a man named Bob, who has the option of re-routing a run-away train to save either a boy or his expensive car (he chooses the car) is also used with flawed logic. Singer thinks "the child was a complete stranger to [Bob] and too far away to relate to in an intimate, personal way" (Singer 2). Singer relates this distance of "greater than yelling distance but within sight" to the distance between American living rooms and impoverished children. If you were at the switch that would re-route a train to possibly save a child, that child is extremely intimate and personal to you. Singer's argument simply doesn't make any sense to me. Firstly, if you say the person who's death you were responsible for, that person becomes extremely personal to you. You would probably never forget them. Secondly, Bob is directly responsible for the child's death. American individuals are not directly responsible for any single death in an impoverished nation. It's not like each American is assigned an ill child to care for. If a child in Brazil died right this second, who's to say is it your fault and your fault alone? Couldn't it easy be mine? Or my neighbor, teacher, or paperboy's fault? In Bob's case, absolutely no one else could be responsible for that child's death.
Singer concludes from Bob's example that "if you still think that it was very wrong of Bob not to throw the switch that would have diverted the train and saved the child's life, then it is hard to see how you could deny that it is also very wrong not to send money to one of the organizations listed above. Unless, that is, there is some morally important difference between the two situations that I have overlooked" (Singer 2). This is the kind of writing that the essay consists of. Singer tells us simply what we are to think, and basses his reasoning on flawed logic. Because of the error's in Singer's logic that I outlined in the previous paragraph, Singer's connection between the Bob example and Americans donating money to children (he himself doesn't even establish a good connection, even with his flawed argument) neither exists nor works. How can Singer tell me what's hard to not see when he can't see the error in his own logic? I think because of this, I was left saying "ummm..." after reading parts like this. And then, to boast his completeness by saying "unless there's something I've overlooked" was just too much for me.
Phonies!
Overall, I just don't like this kind of writing. I don't like it when people try to brainwash you with their point but use half-baked logic. The result for me was, "Wow what a horrible attempt to convince me of your point," not "I really want to help impoverished children now." Perhaps this is a flow in my character that I would rather poke holes in people arguments (oh i DO love doing that) than look past their stupidity for the real meaning. I will certainly and readily concede that Singer had some valid points, don't get me wrong. It's just... if he had written in a more open-minded and logical way, I would have been able to see them more clearly, and his essay would have been infinately more meaningful to me.
Here's a link to the full essay, in case you would like to read it in it's entirety: http://www.utilitarian.net/singer/by/19990905.htm
Please don't let me influence your opinion (hahaha just joking) but do read it for yourself. You may not agree with me at all!
-Alex Y.
Monday, January 22, 2007
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
2 comments:
This is a very well-thought out response to the essay. I never do like opinions where there is a ridiculous ultimatum. And as you could tell by my post, I do agree with your post as well. Just as the kids were born into poverty, we (I'm generalizing Punahou students here) were born into relative financial security. How are we to blame for poverty? If we can set up welfare for our country, we can help develop a source of international welfare. It's unfortunate we're trying to 'fix' the middle east (although in true Bush style, we have no idea how to deal with the Sunni - Shi'a violence). $200 dollars? What about the billions of dollars spend on digging Saddam out of a spiderhole?
And how I am I supposed to listen to a guy who is assumably making a comfortable living writing for the New York Times?
PS. I made some edits to my post, if you're still interested.
Post a Comment