
Ok, so we've all seen Apple's new iPhone. Everybody wants one even though their current phones work perfectly well. Why? Well, partially because Apple products are just cool, partially because [My School] snobs want all the latest things, and partially because Apple just has good marketers. But what is it about this phone that makes it so cool? "The touchscreen!" "The Mac OSX!" "Real Web Access!" "Visual Voice mail!" Well, yeah, that's all nice but does any of that really mean that Apple is doing what it's trying to convince us it's doing?
Apple's slogan for the iPhone is: Introducing iPhone. Apple reinvents the phone. To me, none of those toys (cool as they are) really "reinvent" the phone. It's still a phone. You still just talk into it. It's not like it's a video phone or anything. Isn't the iPhone just a "pre-Apple" phone with a better interface and more expensive operating system? To me, in order for Apple to really "reinvent the phone," they need to bring in something to do with the actual communications part of the phone that is completely unprecedented.
For example, Steve Jobs, in his Keynote introducing the iPhone, claims that the iPhone will do to the cell phone industry what the iPod did to the music industry. Just what did the iPod do to the music industry? Well, in the case of the iPod, Jobs essentially created the market of MP3 players. Sure there were MP3 players before the iPod, but thanks to the iPod, they took off as the new way to take your music with you (versus the CD player). They created the Apple iTunes Music Store, which allows people to download music off the computer (legally, anyway) with great ease (because you need iTunes to sync your iPod anyway). These two advents: getting the music and taking the music in a new way really did change the music industry.
But can the iPhone do the same? To answer that question we have to think about what the iPhone will change about the cell phone industry. In order to allow the iPhone to do visual voice mail, Apple had to demand special treatment from Cingular, their lone carrier, and forced them to rearrange their infrastructure to accommodate the iPhone. This has the potential to change the cell phone industry, as other phone makers might demand special treatment from their carriers in order to remain competitive. It might also seem that in order for new phones to remain competitive with the touchable iPhone, they would need to have interactive touchscreens too. But boy did Apple patent that touchscreen technology!
But the current cell phone industry is extremely competitive, and ever changing. Where the iPod essentially created the field of MP3 players (which wasn't at all competitive before the iPod), the iPhone may have some trouble competing with cheaper, but admittedly less "awe inspiring" phones. "Well," you might argue, "the iPod competed with CD players that were almost a hundred dollars cheaper and look how well it did!" That's very true it did compete with cheaper CD players, but the iPod "reinvented the way you carry your music" by as much as quintupling the amount of music you could carry with you. Remember that CD players only allowed you to listen to 1 CD at a time, plus you had to carry around all those CDs. Therein lays the iPod's appeal. The iPhone simply doesn't have anything this new and amazing. In other words, in my opinion, it's failed to render older phone obsolete. After all, my brick Nokia phone is so old it's not even on the Nokia website anymore, but I can still call Pizza Hut with it.
-Alex Y.
2 comments:
I believe the appeal of new technology lies in the prestige, rather than its practicality. In a recent conversation with my Dad, he remarked on how many Toyota Prius’ that now fill our roads. But, if hybrid vehicles are doing so much for our environment, why did my father not appreciate their presence? He, as one of the first Prius owners on the block, admitted to the status he held when he alone owned a Prius. Just as with the iPhone, the Prius was and is billed as that which would revolutionize the way we perceive technology on a whole. But this simply is not the case for buying. We want to be seen with the “it” thing. We want to have what no one else has, what no one else CAN have. Thus, I understand your cynicism, but realize Steve Jobs never once believed the so-called “reinvention” of the phone would boost iPhone sales. One word, my man: prestige.
Nice review of the phone. I've been shopping around for a handheld lately and decided to wait until I can try out the iPhone. I also watched the keynote, and I have to admit, I was pretty wowed. But you make some pretty good points. I read somewhere that we can never develop anything with an accurate vision of more than 15 years into the future. Things change too much. As far as the iPhone goes, the OSX will be pretty cool.
Post a Comment