So... let's see. Grading an essay. Grading hundreds and hundreds of essays. Written by strangers. All on the exact same topic. Not my ideal job, no, far from it. And yet, the question is: since we have to contribute to the giant stack, how do we get the poor unfortunate judges to think that our writing deserves a good grade?
Mr. Watson says that to get a top score of 6, one must give an answer that "reflects the complexity of the issue at hand." In other words, no black or white yes/no answers. "Ideal" is a grayish in between conditional answer. To me, this is only ideal if you do it right. The consequences for doing this erm.. not right (I don't want to say wrong) are probably catastrophic. If you have a strong gray answer, and you stick to it to the letter throughout your essay, using relevant points, that's perfect. But, if you start to wander, or if your gray answer is the wrong tinge, or if your examples are green with yellow polka dots, you're not going to get a good score. You probably won't even get a decent score -- at least, I wouldn't give you one. I think that to fall slightly below the bar with a black or white answer would be better in the long run than to miss with a gray answer. In other words, to simply answer yes/no is safer. It's easier. And, if you don't think that it's possible to write a grade 6 worthy essay with a solid yes/no answer, read Elise T.'s SAT essay and prepare to be proved wrong.
Also, the feedback that I've gotten from my peers has been very helpful is showing me where I need to work. I've learned what kinds of things make sense, what kinds of things don't, and what things to include next time to make my argument more thorough.
Let's just say, I'm not looking forward to writing an SAT essay that counts anytime soon.
Tuesday, February 27, 2007
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
1 comment:
Read my comment on Elise's essay. I contend that it's not a yes/no answer. Her essay does reflect the complexity of the issue. She just presents it differently and effectively.
Post a Comment