Thursday, February 22, 2007

SAT Practice Essay

*Note: this essay was written without preparation in class with a time limit of 25 minutes.

Most people think that the media controls what defines our culture and gives people things to idolize, thus determining what is important to them. However, in actuality, this isn't entirely true. The media doesn't determine what is important for people.

In today's world, there is a lot of choice. There are a variety of newspapers, magazines, TV stations, and websites all competing for your time and money. Of course, all of these choices are deifferent. We each as individuals, get to decide which newspaper, for example, we want to buy. If our interests are more liberal, we would buy a liberal mewspaper. If you're conservative, a conservative newspapers, and so on. By making choices based on our own preference, we don't allow the media to give us their own point of view. In this way, it is we, not the media, that controls what is important. For example, over the years, the news agencies have come to realize that if they report tragic stories, they will sell more papers. Why? Because when given the choice between a tragic and non-tragic story, people would buy the tragic story. This, since we as consumers have a choice in what we want to buy, we control the media based on our own views.

What is perhaps a perfect example of how the media doesn't shape our beliefs is Web 2.0. Web 2.0 is a new way of thinking about the internet and how we use it. Some examples of Web 2.0 are MySpace, Wikipedia, and YouTube. THe way these sites work is by the user. In other words, people all contribute to these sites and that's what makes them work. Analysts agree that Web 2.0 is a threat to the media as we know it. This is because anyone with a video camera can upload their video to YouTube, for example, and be seen by potentially the entire world. A good examples is "LonelyGirl," a young girl who started shooting videos of herself talking about her day and uploading them to YouTube. LonelyGirl became one of the most viewed people on YouTube and was instantaneously as famous as any of the mainstream media celebrities. THe reason for this is because people found what they liked, which in this case was her, and they found it themselves.

While it may be true to say that the media once controlled what we saw, that's simply not true anymore. With today's variety of choices and the advent of Web 2.0, people are refusing to be force fed by the media and are looking their own food to eat.

4 comments:

Elise said...

I agree that, by choosing the types of media they wish to expose themselves to, people determine their own beliefs. However, we then must wonder where our beliefs, our passions, our gut instincts come from. In our case, most of our beliefs our bred from silimar values held by our parents. But where did our parents come accross these values? And so, and so forth. Though I agree in the inevitability of human bias and human questioning, the truth is, we cannot avoid the media. For all of us, the media governs at least a portion of our thoughts, and by default, our very lives.

Jessica Y said...

I can see your point of view, but I can't bring myself to agree completely. I think it's the American ideal -- what with the preaching of free speech and all -- to believe what you want to believe all by your lonesome, because you want to; however, I don't think we can prevent other ideas from sneaking into our lives so easily. Especially from something as widespread and mainstream as the media.

I think you brought up a good point when you mentioned a liberal-minded person picking up a liberal magazine. That made a lot of sense to me. I mean, I'm not particularly religious, so it doesn't make sense that I'd pick up the Bible or something along those lines. I'd pick up something more to my tastes and interests -- the only thing about that is: Where did those tastes/interests come from?

Clocktower Violinist said...

You brought up a very good point on how it is the readers of the media who choose what they want to read and effectively choose their beliefs, rather than the media having total influence over them. However that leaves me wondering if it's completely possible for a person living in modern society to separate themself from the media entirely...One might argue that there is a reason for everything and thus there must be a reason for doing that. A reason that has to originate in the media in some way or another. Ergo, the media still has its influence over you?

Alex said...

Okay, I see I'm having some issues in defending my "originality of thought" part. Alex W., I don't think it's necessary to remove yourself from the media completely, I think that as long as we as humans can think for ourselves, we have the ability to judge what the media is "feeding" us and determine whether or not it fits in with our personal beliefs. Now you're going to say: Where did those personal beliefs come from? The media? Possibly. But because of new technology, the media as we now have it today is changing. We, the people (in order to form... nvm) ARE the new media. For example, the video we watched in English class about net neutrality was made not by corporations, but by regular, everyday, average Joe's and Jane's who happen to have a strong opinion. Thus, just because the medium we viewed their idea in was the Internet, I don't think it constitues it as "being influenced by the media." At least, not the media that most of us think of. And, again, going back to the liberal vs. conservative argument, if you wanted to get one side of an argument (let's say, abortion), I'm sure you could find persuasive videos on YouTube both for and against it. It all depends on what you type into the searchbox.